Welcome to DeFelice Brothers Pizza Bethlehem, West Virginia
DeFelice Brothers Pizza, located in Bethlehem, West Virginia, is a beloved gem renowned for its tantalizing pizzas and delectable salads. Nestled at 1038 E Bethlehem Blvd, this restaurant has garnered rave reviews from locals and visitors alike. Patrons rave about the flavorful, crisp crust and generously topped pizzas that evoke cherished childhood memories. The friendly staff ensures a welcoming atmosphere, while their customization options cater to individual preferences. Whether it's a classic pepperoni or a Mediterranean white pizza, every dish promises quality and taste. For pizza lovers, DeFelice Brothers is undoubtedly the go-to destination in the Ohio Valley.
-
1038 E Bethlehem Blvd, Wheeling, WV 26003, United States Hotline: +1 304-238-0200
Welcome to DeFelice Brothers Pizza in Bethlehem, West Virginia—a charming eatery renowned for its commitment to quality and tradition in pizza making. Nestled at 1038 E Bethlehem Blvd, Wheeling, WV 26003, this establishment serves as a testament to what authentic pizza should be all about. With a phone number for inquiries at +1 304-238-0200, you’ll be well-equipped to satisfy your pizza cravings.
From my exploration of this beloved local venue, it’s clear why so many patrons return time and again. Take the word of Courtney Goodrich, who states, “Every time we’re in Wheeling, we eat here,” not only for the pizza but also for their “top-notch” salads. This blend of high-quality salads alongside exceptional pizzas offers a well-rounded dining experience.
Then you have Chris Pacifico, who might have endured a longer wait time for delivery but deemed it worthwhile. His enthusiasm encapsulates the experience you can expect at DeFelice—deliciousness that’s worth the wait. I couldn’t help but resonate with Kylie Bechtel's nostalgia, as she recounted savoring the same pizza from her childhood—an experience she fondly wanted to share with her children. This speaks volumes about DeFelice Brothers Pizza, creating connections through culinary nostalgia.
But it's not just about pizza. Patrons rave about their delectable cheese sticks and calzones. A review from Lea Browning highlights the freshness of the food along with the impeccable taste of the sauce, cheese, and crust. This commitment to quality creates an irresistible allure that sets them apart from typical chain restaurants.
Their pizza is heralded for its distinct, flavorful crust that is both buttery and crisp, while the ample cheese pairs perfectly with their pepperoni. As Laura Bebout remarked, the price point of a large pizza, cheesy breadsticks, and a 2L soda for just $29 is not just fair but a value-packed offer. It’s these little details that build a loyal customer base.
To top it off, the staff at DeFelice Brothers Pizza shines in their customer service. Quick to accommodate special requests, they add a personal touch to every order, enhancing your dining experience.
In essence, DeFelice Brothers Pizza in Bethlehem represents more than just a meal; it’s a gathering place filled with cherished memories and delicious food. Whether you're a local or a traveler, this spot is undoubtedly worth a visit. Enjoy the taste of tradition and explore what makes this establishment a true gem in the West Virginia dining scene.
Every time we're in wheeling, we eat here. Absolutely, hands down, the best pizza. The salads are also top notch. We don't leave without getting both!
Pizza was delicious. The delivery time was a bit long (1 hour 15 min) but in the end it was worth the wait. Next time I am in town this is my go to spot
Never ate in. I always pick up my order because I love their pizza and I can not wait for delivery. I recommend them hands down. That is way my rating for atmosphere is the way it is
I have not had DeFelice Pizza in about 25 years. I remember eating it as a kid. It was one of my favorites. I was a little hesitant that it wouldn't be what I remembered. From that first bite, it reminded my of the Ohio Valley area. It was delicious. The staff went out of their way to be accommodating and kind. Thank you again for helping us bring it to my kids and giving them a piece of my childhood
Absolutely the best tasting cheese sticks & calzone we've had in a long time. It was hot, fast, fresh and just good tasting sauce, cheese and crust!! We will always order from here over the regular chains. 10 times better!!
Listen y'all this place actually has the best pizza i have ever had. Tbh. The crust is flavorful And lightly crisped. The cheese is plentiful and marries perfectly with their pepperoni. We got a large pizza, bread sticks, and 2L of soda for 29. With how expensive everything has gotten recently, I really feel like this is a fair price. There was plenty of food leftover as well. all in all I found my new pizza joint when visiting the area.. I might even make a trip there just bc the food is that bomb ,
We just love their pizza and sandwiches. When we ask for light on pizza sauce they always do it for us. And we love the white pizza especially the Mediterranean. The guys who deliver are very friendly. Yay for DeFelice and thank God for such a good food place. ...
Was visiting back in the valley and thought I would try my favorite pizza as a young adult to see how it compares to the adult taste buds test. Wow, it was delicious. The sauce exploded on my taste buds, and the crust was buttery, crunch, and delicious. Taking me back to when we ordered the pizza for family dinners. Brought back a ton of great family memories